A Critical Appraisal of Steve Keen's Critique of Neoclassical Capitalism : A Manifesto

Document Type : Research

Author

Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz

10.30465/crtls.2026.53300.2971
Abstract
Extended Abstract

1. Introduction

Economics stands at a critical intellectual juncture. The Neoclassical paradigm, despite its longstanding dominance, has faced growing criticism for its inability to anticipate major financial crises, adequately explain persistent inequality, and incorporate the ecological constraints confronting modern economies. Among contemporary heterodox economists, Steve Keen has developed one of the most systematic critiques of this paradigm. His The New Economics: A Manifesto (2021), building on earlier works such as Debunking Economics, challenges the foundations of mainstream economics and calls for an alternative framework centered on money, complexity, and nature.

This study critically reappraises Keen’s project through its three interconnected pillars: “Economics without Money,” which challenges the loanable-funds conception and emphasizes endogenous money and private debt; “Economics without Complexity,” which rejects equilibrium-centered analysis and draws on Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis; and “Economics without Nature,” which challenges the treatment of environmental damage in Neoclassical climate models. The paper argues that, despite the strength of these diagnostic tools, Keen’s proposed New Economics remains incomplete because of two limitations: a Power Blind Spot, concerning the social and institutional foundations of power accumulation, and a Geo-Historical Blind Spot, arising from insufficient engagement with non-Western intellectual traditions.

2. Materials & Methods

The study employs a descriptive-analytical and critical-comparative approach. Its primary object of analysis is Keen’s The New Economics: A Manifesto (2021), interpreted alongside his earlier theoretical contributions, particularly Debunking Economics and his work on Minskyan financial instability. Keen’s arguments are reconstructed around money and debt, complexity and instability, and nature and climate change.

The analysis then proceeds comparatively. To examine the Power Blind Spot, Keen’s financial analysis is considered alongside Bichler and Nitzan’s Capital as Power framework, which directs attention to the institutional and social structures through which economic power is accumulated and reproduced. To investigate the Geo-Historical Blind Spot, Islamic Economics—particularly the work of Muhammad Baqir al-Sadr and subsequent contributions by Chapra, Siddiqi, Naqvi, Mirakhor, Hasan, and Ahmad—is examined as a substantive non-Western case. Complementary insights from Marxist political economy, Veblenian institutionalism, feminist economics, and Buddhist and Confucian perspectives are also considered. The analysis is organized across three levels: diagnostic, explaining how contemporary capitalism operates; causal, identifying the structures of power underlying these dynamics; and normative, addressing the principles by which alternative economic arrangements may be evaluated.

3. Discussion & Result

The analysis demonstrates the strength of Keen’s critique at the diagnostic level. First, his treatment of endogenous money restores banks, credit creation, and private debt to macroeconomic analysis. By rejecting the loanable-funds conception and emphasizing private debt dynamics, Keen identifies mechanisms largely obscured in conventional models. Second, his Minskyan approach replaces the assumption of inherent equilibrium with a framework in which periods of stability can generate increasing leverage, speculative behavior, and endogenous instability. Third, his critique of Integrated Assessment Models challenges assumptions and methods that may substantially underestimate the economic consequences of climate change. Together, these arguments establish money, complexity, and ecological constraints as essential components of a more realistic economics.

The critical comparison, however, identifies two important limitations. Keen explains with considerable sophistication how debt-driven instability develops but gives less attention to why particular institutional arrangements repeatedly reproduce concentrated financial and economic power. Incorporating power analysis therefore adds a causal dimension by directing attention to credit allocation, ownership, institutional structures, and the differential capacity of economic actors to shape economic processes.

The second limitation concerns the intellectual scope of Keen’s New Economics. Islamic Economics demonstrates that systematic critiques of interest-based finance, inequality, unrestrained accumulation, and ecological imbalance have also developed outside the dominant Western intellectual tradition. Al-Sadr and subsequent Islamic economists contribute an explicitly normative framework centered on justice (‘Adl), balance (Mizan), risk sharing, and constraints on Riba and Israf. Marxist, Veblenian, feminist, Buddhist, and Confucian perspectives further show that financial instability, unequal power, social reproduction, and ecological limits can be examined through distinct but potentially complementary approaches.

The principal result is therefore a Three-Tiered Synthesis. Keen’s analysis provides the diagnostic level, explaining endogenous money, debt, financial instability, and weaknesses in conventional climate modeling. Power analysis provides the causal level, examining institutional structures and the accumulation and reproduction of economic power. Islamic Economics and other critical traditions provide the normative level, addressing the objectives and ethical criteria by which economic institutions and policies should be evaluated. These three levels are complementary rather than substitutes.

4. Conclusion

Keen’s The New Economics: A Manifesto makes an important contribution to the critique of Neoclassical economics through its reintegration of money and private debt, dynamic conception of financial instability, and challenge to conventional climate economics. Nevertheless, a foundational New Economics requires more than improved financial and dynamic modeling. It must also explain the institutional structures of power and engage seriously with normative and intellectual traditions beyond the conventional Western canon.The proposed Three-Tiered Synthesis therefore combines Keen’s diagnostic tools, the causal insights of power analysis, and the normative resources of Islamic Economics and other critical traditions. Rather than collapsing these traditions into a single theory, this synthesis provides a pluralistic architecture within which financial dynamics, power relations, social justice, and ecological sustainability can be analyzed together. A genuinely New Economics should thus be capable not only of diagnosing economic crises but also of explaining their structural origins and providing an explicit normative basis for evaluating alternative economic institutions and policies.

Keywords

Subjects


Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 17 November 2026

  • Receive Date 02 November 2025
  • Revise Date 09 October 2026
  • Accept Date 16 November 2026