A Critique of "The Birth of Austerity" (2017): Examining the Structural and Substantive Relationship between German Ordoliberalism and Contemporary European Crisis Governance

Document Type : Research

Author

Faculty member, Department of Economics, Faculty of Administrative Sciences and Economics, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

10.30465/crtls.2026.54100.3002
Abstract
The edited volume "The Birth of Austerity: German Ordoliberalism and Contemporary Neoliberalism" (Thomas Biebricher and Frieder Vogelmann, eds., 2017) provides an English-language compilation of foundational ordoliberal texts paired with contemporary analytical essays exploring their links to European Union crisis politics. This article offers a comprehensive critique of the volume situated within the history of economic thought framework. It argues that while the book responds to a critical source gap, its underlying framework suffers from structural and substantive reductionism. Formally, the volume exhibits a clear disconnect between its primary sources and contemporary analyses, failing to maintain a balanced distribution across the three distinct levels of ordoliberal analysis: the competitive order, the social market economy, and European crisis governance. Substantively, the narrow focus on the Freiburg School leads to the omission of figures like Wilhelm Röpke and Alfred Müller-Armack. This erasure leaves the volume unable to distinguish between a dogmatic interpretation of rules and a socially embedded economic system, leading to an incomplete equation of ordoliberalism with contemporary deflationary austerity. Finally, the article demonstrates the analytical utility of these doctrines by applying the ordoliberal critique of state capture and price distortion to the structural challenges of the contemporary Iranian economy.

Keywords

Subjects


Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 16 November 2026

  • Receive Date 28 January 2026
  • Revise Date 10 October 2026
  • Accept Date 15 November 2026