نقد ساختاری و محتوایی فصل «اهداف علم فقه»از کتاب فلسفۀ علم فقه

نوع مقاله : پژوهشی

نویسنده

استادیار بخش فقه و حقوق اسلامی، دانشکده الهیات و معارف اسلامی، دانشگاه شیراز، شیراز، ایران.

چکیده
کتاب فلسفۀ علم فقه، اثر دکتر سعید ضیائی‏‌فر، از معدود منابع منسجم در زمینۀ فلسفۀ فقه و منبعی قابل‏‌توجه برای دروس مربوط به این حوزه در رشته‌‏های فقه و حقوق است. این کتاب درکنار مزایای متعدد اشکالاتی دارد که رفع آن‏‌ها می‏‌تواند بهرۀ بیش‏تری به خوانندگان برساند. فصل چهارم کتاب با عنوان «اهداف علم فقه» ازجمله بخش‏‌هایی است که نیاز به بازبینی ساختاری و محتوایی دارد. در پژوهش حاضر، که به‌روش توصیفی ـ تحلیلی نگاشته شده، مطالب فصل یادشده علاوه‌‏بر نقد ساختاری عمدتاً از پایگاه علم اصول فقه به‌‏نقد گذاشته شده است. «ترتیب طرح مباحث» و «انتخاب عناوین اصلی و فرعی» دو نقد ساختاری به مطالب این فصل است و خلط میان «شریعت و احکام فقهی» با «علم فقه استدلالی» ازیک‏سو و میان «اهداف و مقاصد شارع» با «علت و مناط احکام» ازسوی‏‌دیگر «خلل در تعریف و کارکرد قیاس»، «عقلی به‏‌شمارآوردن کشف علت در قیاس منصوص العلة»، «عدم تبیین معیار برخی مسائل»، و «ذکرنکردن مثال در برخی موارد لازم» ازجمله نقدهای محتوایی به فصل یادشده است.

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات

عنوان مقاله English

Structural and Content Critique of the Chapter 'Objectives of the Science of Jurisprudence' from the Book“Philosophy of the Science of Jurisprudence

نویسنده English

Mahdi Hamidi
Assistant Professor of the Department of Islamic Jurisprudence and Law, Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran
چکیده English

The book "Philosophy of the Science of Jurisprudence" by Dr. Saeed Ziaifar is one of the few coherent resources in the field of the philosophy of jurisprudence and a significant source for courses related to this area in the fields of jurisprudence and law. Despite its numerous advantages, this book has some shortcomings that, if addressed, could provide greater benefit to readers. The fourth chapter of the book, titled "Objectives of the Science of Jurisprudence," is one of the sections that requires structural and content review. In the present study, which has been written using a descriptive-analytical method, the content of the mentioned chapter has been critiqued primarily from the perspective of the science of jurisprudential principles. The "arrangement of discussion topics" and "selection of main and sub-titles" are two structural critiques of the content in this chapter. The confusion between "Sharia and jurisprudential rulings" and "the science of inferential jurisprudence" on one hand, and between "the goals and objectives of the holy legislator" and "the cause and basis of rulings" on the other hand, constitutes a flaw in the definition and function of analogy, Considering the discovery of the cause in a prescribed analogy as rational, the lack of clarification on the criteria for certain issues, and the omission of examples in some necessary cases are among the content-related critiques of the mentioned chapter.
Extended Abstract
Introduction
The book “Philosophy of the Science of Jurisprudence”, written by Hujjat al-Islam, Dr. Saeed Ziyaifar, is one of the first works on the philosophy of Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh) in Iran and remains one of the few available resources on this subject. The book is notable for its well-organized structure, precise categorization of topics, and exploration of various possibilities related to them, alongside extensive research and accurate references to primary sources. Despite these positive attributes, there are some shortcomings in the book that, if addressed in future editions, could enhance its value. One of the most challenging sections is Chapter Four, titled "The Goals of the Science of Jurisprudence". This article provides structural and content-related critiques of this chapter.

Materials & Methods
The data for this study were gathered through library research, utilizing both printed and electronic sources. The analysis was carried out using a descriptive-analytical approach. Initially, some of the topics discussed in Philosophy of the Science of Jurisprudence are summarized, followed by a critical analysis of these issues, primarily from the perspective of the science of Usul al-Fiqh (Principles of Islamic Jurisprudence).

Discussion & Result
Chapter Four of Philosophy of the Science of Jurisprudence consists of introductory discussions, four sub-sections, and two concluding discussions. In the first sub-section, the author delves into the important issue of "Methods for Discovering the Goals of Shari'a," outlining three main, non-integrative methods for discovering the goals of Shari'a: the textual method, the rational method, and the empirical method. The author then mentions the possibility of combining these methods, and in the "Gathering of Evidence" approach, a combination of the aforementioned methods can be utilized. After explaining these methods, the author proceeds with a detailed discussion on the ways in which the goals of the Shari'a can influence Ijtihᾱd (juridical reasoning) and Tafaqquh (religious knowledge). The chapter concludes with a brief reference to "Examples of the Goals of the Shari'a". Several structural criticisms can be made regarding this chapter, including the unsatisfactory placement and order of some key discussions, such as "Methods for Proving the Dimensions of Fiqh Rulings," "Methods for Discovering the Goals of Shari'a," and "Methods for Influencing Ijtihᾱd and Tafaqquh." Another category of critiques pertains to the content of the chapter. The main content-related criticisms addressed in this article include:
1. A blending of "Shari'a and Juridical Rulings" with "The Science of Deductive Jurisprudence" on the one hand, and a mixing of "The Goals and Objectives of the Shari'a" with "The Cause and Grounds of Rulings" on the other. This results in some back-and-forth between these concepts.
2. The author applies the views of the 'Usulī (rationalist) and Akhbᾱrī (traditionalist) scholars on "Ruling and its Cause" to the discussion of "The Goals of the Science of Fiqh," which does not seem to be a solid comparison.
3. In this chapter, the concept of Qīyᾱs Mansūs al-‘Illah (analogy based on a stated cause) is listed as a way of discovering the rational cause of rulings. However, this analogy is, firstly, dependent on recognizing the cause (not its method), and secondly, the method of discovering the cause in this type of analogy is based on textual sources, not rational reasoning.
4. The book's discussion on the scope of the applicability of incomplete induction (istiqrᾱ’ nᾱqis) in discovering the goals of Shari'a is ambiguous, and the foundational argument for it is not established. Similar ambiguities are found in other key sections of the chapter, such as the empirical method and the methods for proving the dimensions of juridical rulings.
5. The definition of analogy (qīyᾱs) and its function, as presented by the respected author, requires serious reconsideration in light of the common terminology used in Fiqh and 'Usūl, and the views of Islamic scholars. In Chapter Four, the unknown object to which analogy is applied to gain knowledge is described as the goal or cause of a ruling. However, according to the traditional definition of analogy, the unknown in an analogy is the ruling of the second subject, not its cause. Proponents of analogy argue that they have identified the cause of the ruling in two subjects—albeit tentatively—and thus derive the ruling of the second subject.

Conclusion
While The Philosophy of the Science of Jurisprudence presents numerous strengths, it also contains points that are open to critique, and it is recommended that these issues be addressed in future revisions. Chapter Four of the book, in particular, is worthy of further consideration and critique in at least two respects: first, the "order of presentation," "selection of main and subsidiary titles," and "the relationship between some of the topics" could be restructured to provide a more logical flow, making the text easier to follow for the reader and improving the proportionality of the various discussions. This would also ensure that significant topics are more effectively represented in the table of contents; second, some content in Chapter Four, both in terms of its internal coherence with other sections of the book and from the perspective of 'Usūl al-Fiqh, requires revision to ensure clarity and consistency

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Sharia
Jurisprudence
The Goals of the Science of Jurisprudence
Jurisprudential Ruling
The Reason for Rulings
آخوند خراسانی، محمدکاظم (1409 ق)، کفایة الأصول، قم: مؤسسۀ آل البیت علیهم السلام.
امام خمینی، سیدروح‌‏ا... (1423ق)، تهذیب الأصول، تقریرات جعفر سبحانی، تهران: مؤسسۀ تنظیم و نشر آثار امام خمینی (ره).
بدری، تحسین (1428 ق)، معجم مفردات اصول الفقه المقارن، تهران: المشرق للثقافة و النشر.
تنکابنی، محمد (1385 ق)، إیضاح الفرائد، تهران: مطبعة الإسلامیة (اخوان کتاب‌چی).
حسینی شهرستانی، محمدحسین (بی‏تا)، غایة المسئول فی علم الأصول، قم: آل البیت.
حکیم، محمدتقی (1418 ق)، الأصول العامة فی الفقه المقارن، قم: مجمع جهانی اهل بیت.
حیدری، علی‏نقی (1412 ق)، اصول الإستنباط، قم: لجنة ادارة الحوزة العلمیة.
سبحانی، جعفر (1383)، رسائل اصولیة، قم: مؤسسۀ امام صادق علیه السلام.
شعرانی، ابوالحسن (1373)، المدخل إلی عذب المنهل فی اصول الفقه، قم: مؤسسۀ الهادی.
ضیائی‏‌فر، سعید (1392)، فلسفۀ علم فقه، قم: پژوهشگاه حوزه و دانشگاه؛ تهران: سمت.
طوسی، محمد بن حسن (1417 ق)، العدة فی اصول الفقه، قم: محمدتقی علاقبندیان.
عراقی، ضیاءالدین (1388)، الإجتهاد و التقلید، قم: نوید اسلام.
علامه حلی، حسن بن یوسف (1425 ق)، نهایة الوصول إلی علم الأصول، قم: مؤسسة الإمام الصادق علیه السلام.
علم‌‏الهدی، علی بن حسین (1376)، الذریعة إلی اصول الشریعة، تهران: دانشگاه تهران.
علیشاهی قلعه‌‏جوقی، ابوالفضل، ابوالحسن بختیاری، و محسن تسلیخ (1395)، «مبانی حجیّت ”ظنّ متآخم به علم“ و سازوکارهای تشخیص آن»، فصل‏نامۀ علمی پژوهشی جستارهای فقهی و اصولی، س 2، ش 5.
کاشف‌‏الغطاء، علی (1381 ق)، النور الساطع فی الفقه النافع، نجف: مطبعة الآداب.
محقق حلی، جعفر بن حسن (1423 ق)، معارج الإصول، لندن: مؤسسۀ امام علی علیه السلام.
مظفر، محمدرضا (1375)، اصول الفقه، قم: اسماعیلیان.
موسوی قزوینی، سیدابراهیم (1371 ق)، ضوابط الأصول، قم: مؤلف.
نجم‌‏آبادی، ابوالفضل (1380)، الأصول (تقریرات درس آقا ضیاء عراقی)، قم: مؤسسة آیة الله العظمی البروجردی لنشر معالم اهل البیت.
نرم‏‌افزار جامع اصول فقه، مؤسسۀ نور.
دوره 25، شماره 3 - شماره پیاپی 121
پاییز 1404
پاییز 1404
صفحه 173-195

  • تاریخ دریافت 13 خرداد 1404
  • تاریخ بازنگری 29 شهریور 1404
  • تاریخ پذیرش 20 مهر 1404